“The most beautiful things are the hardest to reach,” says Leonardo Bottone, the manager at Hotel Palazzo Murat, in Positano. He is talking about Lo Scoglio da Tommaso—the restaurant lounging in the neighboring bay of Nerano on a large wooden pier atop a boulder in the sea, as if it simply took a break from swimming to sun itself on the rocks one day and has stayed put ever since. There are no direct ferry services from the main port towns to Nerano, stuck in its little nook on the southern coast of the Sorrento Peninsula. And the road leading down to it zigzags precipitously until it dead-ends somewhere above the water. So you really need a boat (or, better yet, a friend’s) to get there.

For most visitors arriving by sea, the first impression of Lo Scoglio is a reassuring hand extending from the little jetty beneath the restaurant to steady you as you leap from the launch. “It is about as good a first impression of a restaurant that it’s possible to get,” says Matt Hranek, the travel writer and editor of WM Brown magazine. That hand will probably belong to a De Simone, the family who has run the place for 70 years. “It is always the family that greets you, even now,” says Bottone.