New York City wasn’t built in a day—neither its renowned skyline nor its reputation as the cultural capital of the world. The latter was shaped by decades of superb advertising. Phrases such as “First City of the World,” “City of Marvels,” and “Foremost City in the World” began circulating across Europe in the 19th century. Some of them stuck; some didn’t.

The Big Apple wasn’t always poised to become the world’s poster metropolis. In 1609, when New Amsterdam was established and fur merchants moved in from the Netherlands, England, France, and Germany, an air of lawlessness prevailed. People spat on the street and drank in public. It was so raucous that, for a time, there were more pubs than people.