New York City wasn’t built in a day—neither its renowned skyline nor its reputation as the cultural capital of the world. The latter was shaped by decades of superb advertising. Phrases such as “First City of the World,” “City of Marvels,” and “Foremost City in the World” began circulating across Europe in the 19th century. Some of them stuck; some didn’t.

The Big Apple wasn’t always poised to become the world’s poster metropolis. In 1609, when New Amsterdam was established and fur merchants moved in from the Netherlands, England, France, and Germany, an air of lawlessness prevailed. People spat on the street and drank in public. It was so raucous that, for a time, there were more pubs than people.

In 1870, however, construction on the first skyscrapers began. The Brooklyn Bridge was completed in 1883, and the Statue of Liberty came three years later—the tallest structure in the country—creating a highly marketable visual identity. The advertising machines started to churn.

Over the next three decades, posters, slogans, and relentless publicity equated the city with the majesty of capitalism and of America as a whole. Gilded posters promoted tourism in its early days, the 1870s, inspiring the French and English to sail to America on transatlantic liners. In the 1920s and 1930s, the posters held images of New York’s newly minted train-station complexes. And after the war, they began touting the glamour of air travel.

It was a nuanced game. New York City had to appear appealing while also retaining a veneer of mystery. “Ultimately, to satisfy the desires of tourists and tourism promoters, New York had to be seen and marketed as both American and un-American,” writes Art M. Blake in his 2006 book, How New York Became American, 1890–1924, “treading a fine line between the bold display of difference and the reassuring show of sameness.”

To accompany an exhibition at Poster House, a new book, Wonder City of the World: New York City Travel Posters, compiles advertisements created by accomplished designers such as Leslie Ragan, Michel Kady, and Willy Hanke. The posters span 100 years, and unlike that princess in the French fairy tale, they hail a city that never sleeps. —Elena Clavarino

“Wonder City of the World: New York City Travel Posters” is on view at Poster House, in New York, through September 8

Elena Clavarino is a Senior Editor at AIR MAIL