On my first day at Vahine Private Island, in French Polynesia’s Society Islands, 20 miles from Bora-Bora, I saw more blacktip reef sharks than guests.

“Are you sure it’s safe to snorkel in here?,” I asked Raymonde Tinirauarri Ganivet, the general manager, who was showing us around. Among the property’s authentic Polynesian touches, it turned out, was a “small nursery” for suspiciously docile sharks.