On Tuesday night at the Waverly Inn, Gay Talese was as impossible to reach as Frank Sinatra. But unlike Ol’ Blue Eyes, who notoriously eluded the journalist for three months between 1965 and 1966—resulting in the magazine profile heard around the world, “Frank Sinatra Has a Cold”—Talese was game to talk. In fact, he started the evening by asking whether there was a microphone so he could say a few words and introduce some people. (There wasn’t.)

For the entire night, he was surrounded by a crush of well-wishers who were invited by AIR MAIL’s Co-Editors, Graydon Carter and Alessandra Stanley, to celebrate Talese’s latest book, the journalistic memoir Bartleby and Me: Reflections of an Old Scrivener.