The more elusive a biographical subject, the greater the gleam in the biographer’s eye. Call it the “Jackie O factor”: the unyielding insistence on one’s privacy takes on the aura of a dare, a Come get me if you can enticement. Take the reclusive Booker Prize–winning novelist Anita Brookner, whose hostility to biography—“I shall leave no trace”—has not deterred Hermione Lee from writing a recent thumping 544-page account of her life.
Or take Janet Malcolm, who died in 2021 and is the subject of a new biography, The Absent Woman: The Genius of Janet Malcolm, by Eve Sneider. (A second biography, by Katie Roiphe, is in the works.) Although Malcolm was not as fiercely resistant to the public glare as Brookner—she sold her archives to Yale’s Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library—she was allergic to interviews and to posing for photos and disinclined to reveal her inner life except to close friends.
