The indie film Any Day Now—directed by Eric Aronson—has come and gone. In March, the film, which imagined what happened to 13 paintings stolen from Boston’s Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum in 1990, had a short run in theaters.

But that wasn’t the end. Any Day Now has found a new life on streaming, primarily on Apple TV+ and Amazon Prime. Aronson’s film is disarming, surprisingly warm, and inventive. It has a lot going for it, starting with its star, Paul Guilfoyle.