What does she really know?

There’s nothing new about hidden meanings and messages, intentional or merely perceived, in popular music. Back in the day, “Paul is dead” was practically a growth industry among some Beatles fans: the clues were everywhere; it was obvious he’d been replaced by a double. But Taylor Swift has turned the encouragement of forensic investigation by her fans into an art form. “Everything Swift does means something; nothing is an accident,” wrote Charlotte Ivers in The Times of London. “Thus her social media presence, and her musical output, is littered with cultish symbols and signals worthy of a Dan Brown novel.... You could scroll through TikTok for days and not run out of videos of young women declaring frantically: ‘Guys, I’ve cracked it.’”

“Swift’s community-building approach is in a league of its own,” a record-label manager, Ed Macdonald, told the newspaper. “By inserting subtle—and blatant—clues and self-referential imagery in her art, she is not just encouraging fans to obsess in detail over her current work but actively inviting them to speculate on what she might be up to next.” Which should be crystal clear, if you know where to look.