Prefer six A.M. workouts over late-night dancing? Creatine over cocktails? An exclusive new dating app believes it can do a better job finding your ideal match than Hinge or Bumble—boosting your longevity, or at least your fitness, in the process.

It’s called Ateam, and its founders think they’ve cracked the code to successful online dating by creating a community of fitness-and-wellness obsessives. But relationship experts are divided, the science is somewhat lopsided—and is now really the best moment to introduce a dating app when everyone seems ready to break up with theirs?