Charlie and Emma—played by Robert Pattinson and Zendaya—are the happy couple in The Drama, and if that level of star power (and, in their case, chemistry) isn’t enough to get you into a theater seat, here’s the hook. Days before their wedding, during a seemingly innocent “worst thing you’ve ever done” game, a shocking confession upends the relationship. What began as a lighthearted love story spirals into something darker—a tense psychological thriller. The presence of Alana Haim is the cherry on top of the wedding cake. —Carolina de Armas