Born in London, raised in New Delhi, and the son of a Pakistani politician he barely knew, Aatish Taseer has spent much of his career exploring the complicated worlds of religion, identity, and belonging. His acclaimed first book, Stranger to History (2009), took him on a journey across the Islamic world, from Istanbul to his father’s native Pakistan, in search of his own roots. This week, he sets off for southern Spain, where the ghosts of Muslim rulers linger in Christian cathedrals.

On a burning-hot day in June, under a tent of vacant blue, I stood at the base of the Giralda in Seville—or Ishbiliya, as it was known to the Arabs. The squarish mass of the old minaret, now the bell tower of the world’s largest Gothic cathedral, was a symbol of this land of many natures, where churches sat on the remains of old mosques, themselves built over Visigothic churches. I was in search of Al-Andalus, the Arab name for Muslim Spain, and I meant to follow it east, from Seville to Córdoba to Granada, the way its rulers had lost it: city by city.